When it comes to creating a bestselling book cover design, one of the most common dilemmas authors face is this:
Should your main character’s face appear on the front cover, or should it stay in the reader’s imagination?
The right choice can increase clicks, boost conversions, and enhance your overall author branding strategy—but the wrong one could cost you reader engagement. Let’s explore the pros and cons so you can make the best decision for your genre, your audience, and your book marketing goals.
Benefits of Featuring a Character’s Face on the Cover
1. Emotional Impact and Reader Engagement
Human faces are among the most powerful visual elements in graphic design. A compelling portrait on your custom book cover can establish an instant emotional connection and draw readers in—especially on crowded marketplaces like Amazon or BookTok.
2. Genre Alignment and Reader Expectations
Certain genres practically require character-centric covers. In romance, young adult fantasy, and historical fiction, seeing the protagonist helps readers identify the book’s tone at a glance. A close-up of your hero or heroine can set the mood and meet genre expectations.
3. Strong Visual Identity for Series Branding
If you're designing a series of books, using a recurring character face or silhouette builds strong brand recognition. It can also make your titles visually cohesive across both print book covers and eBook cover designs.
Risks of Putting a Face on Your Book Cover
1. Limiting the Reader’s Imagination
Many readers prefer to visualize characters on their own. A cover that features a model who doesn’t match the character’s description—or the reader’s mental image—can be distracting, or even off-putting.
2. Generic or Overused Stock Photography
Using stock images is common in affordable book cover design, but if the model has appeared on dozens of other covers, your book may look unoriginal. Poor-quality or over-edited faces can also hurt your book’s credibility and professionalism.
3. Symbolic Covers Can Have Wider Appeal
Sometimes, abstract or symbolic elements—a crown, a weapon, a door, or a landscape—can communicate your theme more effectively than a literal face. These designs often work better for literary fiction, mystery, or science fiction genres and stand out in thumbnail views.
Key Questions to Ask Before Choosing Your Cover Direction
Is your book character-driven or plot-driven?
For deeply personal, character-led stories, a face might make sense. For complex worlds or action-heavy plots, a symbolic design might be more effective.
What’s trending in your genre’s cover design?
Study the top-selling book covers in your category. Successful design aligns with reader expectations while still being unique.
Do you have the budget for high-quality design?
If you can’t invest in custom photography or illustration, showing a face might backfire. In that case, consider a premade book cover with a strong conceptual image.
Are diversity and representation key themes in your book?
Then it’s vital that any character imagery is accurate, inclusive, and sensitively portrayed. Authentic representation is a core element of both book cover illustration and interior book design today.
Final Verdict: Face or No Face?
There’s no one-size-fits-all approach in professional book cover design. Whether you show your character’s face or not, your decision should support your overall book marketing strategy, genre, and tone. A powerful book cover isn’t just art—it’s your first and most important sales tool.
Need help deciding? Browse our curated selection of custom covers, premade designs, and expert advice at Book Cover World.
→ Let’s bring your story to life—one unforgettable cover at a time.
Add new comment